Current:Home > MyCourt Sides With Trump on Keystone XL Permit, but Don’t Expect Fast Progress -Quantum Finance Bridge
Court Sides With Trump on Keystone XL Permit, but Don’t Expect Fast Progress
View
Date:2025-04-15 11:09:43
A federal appeals court on Thursday threw out a lower court decision to halt construction of the Keystone XL pipeline. But several major obstacles remain to the controversial project’s progress, ensuring that the much-delayed Keystone XL will likely not be built soon.
The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals decision hands a victory, at least for now, to the Trump administration and tar sands oil interests that have sought to jump-start construction of the northern leg of the pipeline from Alberta to Nebraska.
President Barack Obama had decided in 2015 that Keystone XL should not be built, saying it wouldn’t serve the U.S. national interest. But in one of his first acts in the White House, President Donald Trump signed an executive order reversing that decision and directing the State Department to issue a construction permit. The issue has been litigated ever since.
Last November, a federal district court judge in Montana stopped construction of the pipeline, ruling that the Trump administration had failed to fully take into account the pipeline’s impact on the environment, including the climate. “The Trump administration “simply discarded prior factual findings related to climate change to support its course reversal,” wrote Judge Brian Morris of the United States District Court for Montana.
In response, Trump scrapped the pipeline’s State Department approval in March and issued in its place a new presidential permit for Keystone XL, arguing that such a permit, originating in the White House, does not need to abide by federal environmental reviews.
Keystone XL’s owner, TC Energy, and the administration then appealed the Montana court’s decision to the Ninth Circuit Court, asking the panel of judges to throw out the lower court’s ruling since the State Department permit had been revoked.
The Ninth Circuit ruled in favor of the administration and the company.
“We are pleased with the ruling,” said Matthew John, a spokesman for TC Energy, formerly known as TransCanada. “We look forward to advancing the project.”
Jackie Prange, a senior attorney with the Natural Resources Defense Council, part of a coalition that sued to stop the pipeline, said in a statement that advocates are exploring “all available legal avenues” to halt Keystone XL.
Oil production from the tar sands, or oil sands, is among the most carbon-intensive, and environmental groups and landowners have opposed new pipeline infrastructure, both over the tar sands’ impact on climate change and over the fear of oil spills. Two other pipelines connecting the Alberta tar sands region to refineries are facing challenges in Minnesota and Michigan.
Keystone XL Still Faces Legal Challenges
The appeals court ruling does not mean there will be speedy progress on the pipeline, which has been mired in legal challenges for a decade.
In March, TC Energy said it would not be able to begin construction this year because of uncertainty created by various lawsuits. One case still pending before the Nebraska State Supreme Court challenges the pipeline’s latest planned route through the state. The project also still needs some permits from the Army Corps of Engineers and the Interior Department.
Opponents of Keystone XL have successfully stymied the project’s completion for years with legal challenges over threats to regional drinking-water aquifers, streams, wildlife habitat and the global climate.
Flooding Raises Another Risk in Nebraska
This spring’s catastrophic flooding in Nebraska also highlighted risks the pipeline could face from erosion and from debris in rivers scouring the river beds that the pipeline would cross under.
The threat to pipelines from erosion prompted the Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration, the federal regulator responsible for the safe operation of the country’s energy pipelines, to issue an advisory a month ago to pipeline owners. It urged them to institute safeguards after a recent spate of accidents from soil shifting around pipelines.
In the last decade, fast currents and high floodwaters exposed two pipelines in the Yellowstone River in Montana that both ruptured, leaking a total of about 93,000 gallons of oil.
veryGood! (9223)
Related
- Macy's says employee who allegedly hid $150 million in expenses had no major 'impact'
- SCS Token Leading the Trading System Revolution at SSW Management Institute
- Third man pleads guilty in connection with threats and vandalism targeting New Hampshire journalists
- CoinBearer Trading Center: What is decentralization?
- $73.5M beach replenishment project starts in January at Jersey Shore
- With ‘flat’ wedding rates, Vegas officials and chapels want more couples to say ‘I do’
- Matthew and Camila McConaughey go pantless again to promote tequila brand
- CoinBearer Trading Center: Exploring the development of fully on-chain NFT games
- New Mexico governor seeks funding to recycle fracking water, expand preschool, treat mental health
- Judge’s ruling temporarily allows for unlicensed Native Hawaiian midwifery
Ranking
- DoorDash steps up driver ID checks after traffic safety complaints
- After losing an Olympic dream a decade ago, USA Judo's Maria Laborde realizes it in Paris
- The best 3-row SUVs in 2024 for big families
- Beaconcto Trading Center: The Importance of the US MSB License
- Apple iOS 18.2: What to know about top features, including Genmoji, AI updates
- Puerto Rico bans discrimination against those who wear Afros and other hairstyles on diverse island
- Iowa judge lifts injunction blocking state's 6-week abortion ban
- Prosecutors file Boeing’s plea deal to resolve felony fraud charge tied to 737 Max crashes
Recommendation
Romantasy reigns on spicy BookTok: Recommendations from the internet’s favorite genre
CoinBearer Trading Center: Exploring the development of fully on-chain NFT games
Massachusetts bill would require businesses to disclose salary range when posting a job
Trump's DJT stock falls as Kamala Harris hits campaign trail
Tom Holland's New Venture Revealed
Blaze Pizza franchisee hit with child labor violations in Nevada, fined over $277K
How USA Basketball saved coach Jim Boylen after he lost brother, marriage, NBA job
BETA GLOBAL FINANCE: Leading the Wave of Decentralized Financial Innovation